Is Thinking You're Better Than Other People Holding You Back Socially?

Some lonely and socially awkward people are really insecure and self-effacing and feel like they're detestable nobodies. I've noticed a tendency for other people to have a different attitude, where they see themselves as a bit above everyone else. There are two sides to this mentality. One is thinking there's something about you that makes you superior to other people. You think you're smarter, deeper, different, or that you have more evolved beliefs and priorities than them. The other side is seeing everyone else as having a bunch of negative traits, that they're dumb, shallow, and selfish. The result is you feel like you can't relate to other people, that you're cut off from them, and like you're misunderstood and forced to walk your own path through life.

This attitude can also appear as a kind of hostile over-pickiness in who you want to hang around. Some people are too choosy about their friends in a fairly benign way. They have overly high standards, but don't hold any ill will towards people. A more toxic form of pickiness is when you think everyone's an idiot. No matter who you meet, there's always something wrong with them and you never feel anyone is good enough to hang around or be friends with. You may think you want to have more friends, but whenever you meet new people, or consider the possibility of deepening a relationship with an acquaintance, you find something to make you think twice. No one's perfect, so if you're looking for a reason to write someone off, you'll always find it.

In a shock to no one, I don't think having this view will do you any favors. Your attitude may come through and put people off, or it may cause you to turn away perfectly reasonable social opportunities.

Reasons someone may come to think they're above other people

To some degree everyone feels a little above the crowd sometimes. The world really can be a stupid place, it may be human nature to tend to see yourself as mildly superior, and plenty of people go through phases where they're down on society and their fellow man. However, I think the attitude I mentioned above goes beyond that. Here's my take on some of the dynamics laying under this way of thinking:

Ego protection

This one isn't a stretch. Thinking you're better than other people is a good way for your ego to defend itself from being damaged. It would sting to consider the possibility that you're not doing well socially because you have weak spots or that you've been going about things the wrong way. It feels better to tell yourself things like:

Rejecting people before they reject you

This is another well-known point. Insecure people will often look for reasons to reject others, to pre-emptively protect themselves from the pain of being rejected themselves down the road, which their low self-esteem makes them certain is inevitable. Being the one to do the rejecting allows them to save face in a way. Or maybe their insecurity makes them want to save other people the trouble of wasting their time on a supposed loser like them.

Lack of perspective

Feeling superior is based on a lack of perspective. Are you probably "above" some people? Sure, but not almost everyone. It's easy to believe you're a different breed when you don't interact with other people that much, or in a meaningful way. If you were around other people more you'd quickly accumulate evidence that you aren't the special flower you believe you are. You'd also learn not everyone is some mindless consumer. Similarly, it's easy to be picky when you don't have many actual friends, and your overly high standards seem reasonable in your head. When you actually hang around the types of people you'd previously have turned away, you realize they're often perfectly fine, and that all the criteria you thought were so important really don't matter.

The relativity of being "better" than someone

Feeling that you're above other people is a cheap source of self-esteem because the concept is so vague that anyone can build their own subjective case for why they're superior. They can cherry pick a trait (which they're strong in, naturally), decide it's a true indicator of superiority, and use that as evidence that they're above the masses. A smart person can tell themselves they're 'better' because they're intelligent. A non-intellectual person can say they're 'better' because they're down to earth and have street smarts instead of a head full of useless facts. Someone can also adjust their measure of betterness depending on what group they compare themselves too, so they always come out favorably (compared to regular people they're better because they're smart, compared to people who are also intelligent they're better because they're more well-rounded, etc.)

Give people a chance, and don't get too high on yourself

The point of this article isn't hard to figure out. If you give everyone the benefit of the doubt you'll often find that many people are much more layered and interesting than you might have thought at first. Here's an article that goes into more detail about the ways people may seem more shallow than they actually are.