When People Don't Notice You've Changed
This site is about getting past social awkwardness, but the problem this article covers has a broader scope. Often when you feel like you've changed, by becoming more socially polished or in some other way, it seems like no one else acknowledges it. You've done a lot of new things, you've put a lot of work into yourself, you feel like a different person, but everyone still treats you the same way. They still use the same annoying labels to describe you. You're still held back by your past reputation.
The need to have people acknowledge the new and improved you can be quite powerful. Sometimes this need is for a practical reason. In order to get what you want, everyone has to update their opinions of you (e.g., so they'll give you a shot as a friend). At other times you'd like people to think you've changed more to heal your own ego. You want to feel like you're not the screw up you used to be, and are a little too emotionally invested in outside feedback. If someone mentions offhand how outgoing you are it makes your day. But if an acquaintance casually tells you you're quiet, it totally deflates you. Someone's core motivation for changing could be they want to get a different reaction from others.
If you're preoccupied with people seeing you a certain way, there are often a few individuals whose opinion you care about more than others. You have a strong urge to prove yourself to them. Maybe you respect their judgment ("If they acknowledge I've changed, then I officially have!") , or they've shunned you in the past and you feel you have to win them over out of principle ("They think I'm weird do they? Grrrr... I'll show them."). These people could be family members, people you look up to, people you see as belonging the group who used to not give you any credit, etc.
Here are my thoughts:
It's better if you just don't care about people noticing you've changed
And of course this is easier said than done. If you can do it though, it's so much simpler when you're just not obsessed with people acknowledging how different you are now compared to before. It's better if your standards for success aren't based on outside validation. Change to be happier for yourself and to access better things in life, not so you can get approval from people to salve your self-esteem. That's not to say you should never care about people's feedback or opinions, but don't make it your sole reason for trying to transform.
You may not have changed as much as you think
People sometimes vow to change, embark on a self-help quest, and after a few months feel like they've totally evolved. Then they desperately want everyone to see them differently, and get peeved when nobody seems to appreciate how new and improved they are.
The reality is they haven't really changed as much as they feel they have. They've done a ton of reading and thinking about their problems. They feel like they've made huge mental breakthroughs. They've felt that mental high you get from making progress at something. But those internal feelings are out of proportion to how much they've tangibly fixed things.
Like I was saying, people can get really mentally invested in not being the person they used to be. They can fool themselves and think they've accomplished everything they need to in half a year. They can believe that just because they put a lot time and of emotional effort into it, that it must have paid off. True changes are hard to make, and they don't come overnight.
Other people mostly only notice big, external changes
Although they can feel significant at the time, a lot of the changes you make are subtle. You have to change in a specific trait quite a bit before it really starts to strike other people. That may take a while. Another thing is that your internal changes often aren't noticeable at all. Changing an attitude or outlook on life may feel really different to you, but if your outer behavior remains the same, it won't register with anyone else.
It sometimes takes a while for people to notice changes
If you've really changed, to a degree that other people will notice, they often don't pick up on it right away. Sometimes they do, but you can't count on it. Of course your ego wants everyone to catch on instantly and give you the gratification of being told how much better you are now, but it usually takes your changes a while to sink in. Say you have a new way of acting in certain situations. If act like that once, other people will probably chalk it up as a one-time fluke. Do it a few more times over the next few weeks and they may get this vague inkling that something is different. Eventually it may all come together and they'll look back and realize you've actually been acting differently for the past while.
People may also see some traits in either-or terms. Like someone may divide people into "sociable" and "withdrawn". If you're normally inhibited, and become less so, you may still be quiet enough to fall into their "withdrawn" category.
A related idea is that if you've burned people in the past, perhaps by being very socially off-putting or insensitive, they may have noticed a change in you, but they're understandably skeptical and wary. If you've made a bad enough impression back in the day, you may never win them over. With other people, you have to really prove you're a different person through your actions over time before they warm up to you.
People won't always say you've changed out loud
When you want people to acknowledge you've changed, what that often means is you want them to say it out loud in front of you. But if someone notices you've changed they may not feel the need to say anything. How often do you hear people suddenly go, "Wow man, you've totally changed! And you're so much more likable and worthy now!!!"? It just isn't everyone's style to say things like that. They might mention it to someone else, but not to you. They may even purposely not want to complement you or give you the satisfaction of letting you know they think you've improved.
People often tend not to notice when someone changes
Our minds function in a way that can make it hard for us to notice others have changed. If someone has a preconception that you're shy and uptight, they may overlook any of your behaviors that are outgoing. Naturally, as soon as you seem quiet for a second they can say to themselves, "See? What a shy person."
Someone may also have a stake in seeing you a certain way and be resistant to your changing. For example they may like a dynamic where you play the role of their meek, harmless sidekick. They may feel threatened if you start being more fun and confident. Or if you were always unassertive, a pushy friend who's used to getting what they want from you may react negatively if you suddenly start to stand up for yourself. More simply, if you suddenly start acting differently someone may just feel vaguely off balance and like they want things to be the way they've always been. They could even have a worldview that "people don't change", and resist any evidence that suggests otherwise. If someone perceives you've changed in a way they don't like, the classic response is to try to force you back into your old role.
People are also, on the whole, mentally lazy. They don't have the energy to keep an eye out for every little change in how you interact with them. When you chat, in a sense they're not really talking with the real you. They're more responding to a rough impression they formed of you years ago. Reacting to you through that lens may suit their purposes just fine, and they may not get anything out of scrutinizing your every action for signs you've become a new person.
You may not be interacting with people in a situation where your changes show up
Say you've spent a lot of time trying to become more comfortable talking to strangers. If you're hanging around your family or old friends, why would they notice that? Being confident with new people has nothing to do with having dinner at your parents, so any progress you've made in that area won't be apparent to them.
You come across to every person in a different way
Depending on the context you interact with them in, and how your personalities and interests mesh up, everyone will see you a bit differently. Your supervisor, who you want to act professional around, may think the "real you" is serious and reserved. Your friend, who you feel really comfortable with, and who loves your sense of humor, may see the "real you" as goofy and lighthearted. You can change, but if you have a relationship with someone that tends to bring out traits you've kept the same, they may never get a glimpse of your new side.
Some people may never change their opinion of you
For all the reasons mentioned above, some people may never come to see you differently from how they've always thought of you. Like a family member's view may be too entrenched, because they've known you so long, to ever think you could act another way. You can't win them all. It can take a weight off your shoulders to accept this. Again, it's easier just not to care about this stuff, but that attitude's not always something you can switch on or off just like that.
You're more likely to get positive feedback from new people
When you're around someone you've known a while they tend to treat you like they always have. If they think you've changed they often don't show it. People you've just met are more likely to respond to the "new you". They don't have preconceptions about what type of person you are, and can see you with fresh eyes. With people you know, their view of you is warped by baggage and notions they've already formed. So if you want that boost of being told how awesome you are now, strangers are more likely to give it to you.
Don't be too selective in what feedback you hear
Negative comments have a tendency to stick out in our minds. But if you care about having your changes validated by other people, it can help to pay attention to the larger pattern. If three of them say you're more fun than you used to be, and one says you're boring, it's easy to latch on to the single harsh remark as evidence you're still the loser you always were. Of course, the majority did say you're more fun now.
If your past reputation is really holding you back, you may just have to change your environment
Sometimes no matter what you do, you can't shake your old reputation, and that prevents you from getting the things you want (friends, respect, etc.). No matter how much you try to convince people you're different, it falls on deaf ears and you keep getting the same poor results you always have. At times the right decision is to cut your losses and move on to a better environment, where the new people you meet will be able to see you objectively. If you're in school you may get to move to a different setting automatically when you graduate. Or you may have to take active steps to switch jobs or move out of your small town.